top of page

N.2/2025 L'eredità di Pierre Hadot. Per una filosofia come modo di vivere

Contrappunto e logica della disgregazione.
Edward Said lettore di Theodor W. Adorno

Cristian Perra

Published in June, 2026

Counterpoint and the Logic of Disintegration: Edward Said as a Reader of Theodor W. Adorno
Screenshot 2026-07-08 alle 10.59.14.png

Abstract

This article analyzes the concept of counterpoint in the work of Edward Said, arguing that his methodology is based on Adorno’s Logik des Zerfalls. Said recognized himself as a follower of Adorno, especially concerning the concept of counterpoint in music, and applied it to the analysis of colonialism. For both authors, counterpoint is the method to deconstruct the totality, showing the impossibility of the reconciliation between the universal and the particular. Said’s work can be read as an attempt to disintegrate the monolithic concept of the colonial world by highlighting the excesses and contradictions that emerge from the colonial discourse. The article highlights the influence of Adorno’s thinking on Said’s analysis of colonialism and his critique of the totalizing narratives produced by the colonial system. Said’s counterpoint approach unveils the suppressed polyphony beneath the monophony of power, exposing the underlying power dynamics of colonial discourse. This reading of Said’s work, therefore, suggests that the concept of counterpoint is central to his critique of colonialism and his understanding of the relationship between culture, power, and representation.

Keywords

Counterpoint, Logik des Zerfalls, Colonialism, Totality, Edward Said, Theodor W. Adorno.

DOI

10.53129/gcsi_02-2025-11

G.C.S.I. - Giornale Critico di Storia delle Idee
Rivista internazionale di filosofia

Direzione Editoriale:
Andrea Tagliapietra e Sebastiano Ghisu

Direttore Responsabile:
Giovanni Campus

  • facebook

Autorizzazione del Tribunale di Sassari n.455 del 14/7/2008 - ISSN 2035-732X  ISSN(cartaceo) 2240-7995

Credits:

evenice-logo_edited_edited.png
bottom of page